Hotmail  |  Gmail  |  Yahoo  |  Justice Mail
powered by Google
WWW http://www.JusticeForNorthCaucasus.com

Add JFNC Google Bar Button to your Browser Google Bar Group  
 
 
Welcome To Justice For North Caucasus Group

Log in to your account at Justice For North Caucasus eMail system.

Request your eMail address

eMaill a Friend About This Site.

Google Translation

 

 

Window On Eurasia: Russia’s Federal Districts Aren’t Working In Current Form, Daghestani Says

posted by eagle on January, 2011 as Imperialism


MONDAY, JANUARY 17, 2011

Window on Eurasia: Russia’s Federal Districts Aren’t Working in Current Form, Daghestani Says

Paul Goble

Staunton, January 17 – Russia’s system of federal districts, which stand between Moscow and the subjects of the federation, needs to be fundamentally revised if it is to be effective and more than home for politicians who have failed elsewhere or the locus for the further growth of the bureaucracy, according to a Daghestani commentator.
In an article on the first anniversary of the creation of the North Caucasus Federal District, Albert Esedov says that many Daghestanis had great expectations for the new entity all the more so because President Dmitry Medvedev unlike his predecessor Vladimir Putin stressed the economic role of this institution (gazeta-nv.ru/content/view/5269/109/). 
And in the past year, there have been "several positive moves forward” – of "at the very least, a number of investment programs and plans have been adopted.” But there have been far more "shortcomings,” and these in turn raise some larger questions about the federal districts and how and even if they should develop in the future.
Among the problem with the North Caucasus Federal District, Esedov says, are the fact that "up until now the permanent address of the residence of the presidential plenipotentiary is not known, [its] organs and structures have not been formed, [its] website has not been launched, and there are no offices” to which the population can come with its problems.
Moreover, and in contrast to the situation in all other federal districts, no one has been talking about "the need to establish a federal university,” even though "by an irony of fate, all the major higher educational institutions of the region have already been united in a Southern Federal University,” except for Daghestani institutions which aren’t included.
But these are technical issues compared to some of the larger problems the existing federal districts present, Esedov says. Some of them don’t correspond to geography. The Southern Federal District, "which initially by the irony of fate was called the North Caucasus” one, for example, includes both subjects adjoining the Caucasus and some adjoining them.
And the North Caucasus Federal District doesn’t include Adygeya but does include Stavropol kray, the latter, Esedov suggests included by Moscow in order to "’correct’ the ‘less than good’ statistics” of the year-old federal district but an arrasngement with which Stavropol officials and residents are not pleased.
This "problem of the lack of correspondence of the borders with federal districts and the structures of regional identity at times,” the Daghestani analyst continues, "makes more difficult the work of the center with regions, by creating the phenomenon of ‘dissatisfied’ regions which resist integration in the framework of the existing federal districts.”
Putin set up the system in order to strengthen "the single system of executive power” by "distributing functions and authority of the organs of state power on three levels: the federal center, the federal districts and the subjects of the Federation.” But, Esedov points out, "this is [only] in theory.”
Moscow has never explained in detail why three-level federalism is necessary or defined in law the status of the federal districts. A major reason for this is that "all this would require constitutional amendments,” a step that the Moscow leadership has so far been quite reluctant to take.
Nor have their been "the necessary amendments” to the constitutions of the federal subjects, and consequently, one still has no reason, the Daghestani expert continues, "to consider the federal district as a link of the new territorial arrangement of the state.”
And Esedov continues, this federal innovation has taken place at a time when Moscow has been talking about amalgamating federal units, many of which have longstanding historical traditions and the destruction of which "in the name of the formal expansion of territory could be a political mistake not subject to correction.”
Because the federal districts have not been codified in law, their operations have depended in every case on "the personal factor,” on the individual in the top position, a pattern that further retards the institutionalization of the Russian political system even while allowing a place for more bureaucracy and for politicians who have failed elsewhere.
Finally, he points out, "there are no analogues in world practice to the three-level system of federalism” that Putin and Medvedev appear to be trying to put in place. Moreover, "the tendencies of development of federalism abroad are directed at the democratization of national political systems under conditions of decentralization and self-development of social systems.”
Such goals, Esedov argues, canb e achieved "only under conditions of systemic de-bureaucratization of the state and the construction of an open civil society,” exactly the opposite direction in which the Russian Federation with its federal districts is currently moving.
One possibility for Russian state development might be the elimination of first the presidents and heads of regions, then the elimination of regional parliaments, and finally the formation of real governments in the federal districts. That would be "logical,” he concludes, but it would certainly spark serious resistance.

comments (0)


1 - 1 of 1



 RSS FEED


New Posts



Search Imperialism



Imperialism



Archive


 january 2015

 march 2014

 november 2013

 september 2013

 july 2013

 march 2013

 february 2013

 january 2013

 december 2012

 november 2012

 september 2012

 july 2012

 april 2012

 february 2012

 july 2011

 june 2011

 april 2011

 march 2011

 february 2011

 january 2011

 december 2010

 november 2010

 october 2010

 september 2010

 august 2010

 july 2010

 june 2010

 may 2010

 april 2010

 march 2010

 february 2010

 january 2010

 december 2009

 november 2009

 october 2009

 september 2009

 august 2009

 july 2009

 june 2009

 may 2009

 april 2009

 march 2009

 february 2009

 december 2008

 november 2008

 october 2008

 september 2008

 august 2008

 july 2008

 june 2008

 may 2008

 april 2008

 march 2008

 february 2008

 january 2008

 december 2007

 november 2007

 october 2007

 september 2007

 august 2007

 july 2007

 june 2007

 may 2007

 april 2007

 march 2007

 february 2007

 january 2007

 december 2006

 november 2006

 october 2006

 september 2006

 august 2006

 july 2006

 june 2006

 may 2006

 april 2006

 march 2006

 february 2006

 january 2006

 december 2005

 november 2005

 october 2005

 september 2005

 august 2005

 july 2005

 june 2005

 may 2005

 april 2005

 january 2005

 july 2000





Acknowledgement: All available information and documents in "Justice For North Caucasus Group" is provided for the "fair use". There should be no intention for ill-usage of any sort of any published item for commercial purposes and in any way or form. JFNC is a nonprofit group and has no intentions for the distribution of information for commercial or advantageous gain. At the same time consideration is ascertained that all different visions, beliefs, presentations and opinions will be presented to visitors and readers of all message boards of this site. Providing, furnishing, posting and publishing the information of all sources is considered a right to freedom of opinion, speech, expression, and information while at the same time does not necessarily reflect, represent, constitute, or comprise the stand or the opinion of this group. If you have any concerns contact us directly at: eagle@JusticeForNorthCaucasus.com


Page Last Updated: {Site best Viewed in MS-IE 1024x768 or Greater}Copyright © 2005-2009 by Justice For North Caucasus ®