Hotmail  |  Gmail  |  Yahoo  |  Justice Mail
powered by Google
WWW http://www.JusticeForNorthCaucasus.com

Add JFNC Google Bar Button to your Browser Google Bar Group  
 
 
Welcome To Justice For North Caucasus Group

Log in to your account at Justice For North Caucasus eMail system.

Request your eMail address

eMaill a Friend About This Site.

Google Translation

 

 

NYT: Empty Chairs, Empty Tables, Empty Beds

posted by eagle on July, 2010 as North Caucasus



MOSCOW — The rooms depicted in Mari Bastashevski’s project, "File 126 (Disappearing in the Caucasus),” are neat as a pin, suffused with light, as carefully arranged as a brand new doll house.

You have to examine them closely to find what she calls "the dent on the pillow”: a sign that, until a minute ago, someone occupied this space; that someone stepped out expecting to return.

What is not apparent in the images, made in the southern Russian provinces of Chechnya, Dagestan and Ingushetia, is the violence of the disappearances. The narratives have a numbing sameness — 20 or 30 masked men bursting into a house at 4 a.m.; extended families ordered to lie face-down on the ground; young men in their bathrobes, forced into armored vehicles without license plates.

Ms. Bastashevski, 30, a Russian-born artist who now lives in the West, had read the case files before she began visiting families. Human rights organizations in the Russian North Caucasus have spent years documenting the abductions of young people, which they attribute to the state security forces conducting a brutal counter-insurgency campaign.

When she entered the houses, stories poured out, over cups of tea, in two- and three-hour torrents. Some verged on madness, like the genteel lady who was certain, after five years, that her sons were still alive in a secret prison in the forest, if only she could reach them.

All were infused with the desperate hope that a visitor from the West — often the first they had ever had in their homes — could somehow save their children.

Sometimes, parents who had lost a son to abduction would ask Ms. Bastashevski if she would marry another son. "We’re not talking about, ‘You’re a pretty lady, let’s make a good deal,’” she said. "It is like, ‘Could you marry my son so he could leave?’ Well, what do you say? There is nothing to say.”

What came to her was the quietest of all solutions: She would photograph the homely spaces the missing men had inhabited, many of them preserved in anticipation of their return. Five families turned into dozens and then hundreds. She edited her photos into a portfolio named after Article 126, the category for abduction in the Russian criminal code, which is being exhibited in New York and Washington by the Open Society Foundation.


Mari BastashevskiIn Dagestan in March 2008, Eldar Navruzov was arrested by armed, masked and camouflaged law-enforcement officers, taken to an undisclosed location and coerced by torture into saying he was a Wahhabi Muslim. He was released from detainment in February 2009 but forbidden to travel until his trial. Two months later, as he was returning home from work, he was confronted by two men who jumped out of a car and ordered him to stop. Mr. Navruzov escaped by running home screaming, "They’re kidnapping me!” Last November, however, he disappeared and has been missing ever since.

It helped that she had her own nest to return to. Like most Westerners who do work in the North Caucasus, Ms. Bastashevski had planned a short trip. A month, she thought, would be enough to get what she needed. But her plans were upended when she met Natalia Estemirova, 50, a former schoolteacher who had become a one-woman human rights clearing-house in Chechnya.

A boisterously funny mother hen who shared Ms. Bastashevski’s affection for Harry Potter, Ms. Estemirova lived in a two-room apartment in central Grozny, beset by water and power outages and a half-demented cat. Ms. Estemirova knew how dangerous her work was. She had sent her 15-year-old daughter to live with relatives in central Russia. So she had room.

"Natalia turned my head around completely, so I just moved in,” Ms. Bastashevski said. They developed a routine. If Ms. Bastashevski got carried away with a photo shoot and stayed out after dark, Ms. Estemirova would chase her down to make sure she was all right, and then she would come home to the safety of the apartment, and they would sit across the kitchen table and talk about their days.

"She was taking care of me,” Ms. Bastashevski said. "It kind of always was serious, but it felt safer — she could do her job, and be O.K., and she’s looking after me, and I’m going to be careful.”

Add this to the list of empty spaces: One year ago this week, Ms. Estemirova was snatched by four men outside her apartment building and forced into a car as she left for work. Her lifeless body was found a few hours later by the side of a highway, with gunshot wounds to the head and chest.

Since then, Ms. Bastashevski has made three trips to the North Caucasus, where the unfinished work only seems to proliferate. There is nothing lighthearted about it now; she still has to stop herself from dialing Ms. Estemirova’s number when she has a question. She realizes she must return to photograph her friend’s apartment as part of her project — to capture "the gap,” as she puts it, "between life before and after.” She went as far as retrieving the keys to the apartment from a neighboring village. But she passed by several times and was unable to turn down the street.

"I couldn’t find it in myself to go there,” she said. "I kind of had to put it off.”


Ellen Barry is a New York Times correspondent in Moscow.


http://lens.blogs.nytimes.com/2010/07/13/showcase-186/


comments (0)


1 - 1 of 1



 RSS FEED


New Posts



Search North Caucasus



North Caucasus



Archive


 january 2015

 january 2014

 december 2013

 november 2013

 october 2013

 september 2013

 august 2013

 april 2013

 march 2013

 january 2013

 december 2012

 november 2012

 october 2012

 september 2012

 august 2012

 july 2012

 june 2012

 may 2012

 april 2012

 march 2012

 february 2012

 november 2011

 august 2011

 july 2011

 june 2011

 may 2011

 april 2011

 march 2011

 february 2011

 january 2011

 december 2010

 november 2010

 october 2010

 september 2010

 august 2010

 july 2010

 june 2010

 may 2010

 april 2010

 march 2010

 february 2010

 january 2010

 december 2009

 november 2009

 october 2009

 september 2009

 august 2009

 july 2009

 june 2009

 may 2009

 april 2009

 march 2009

 january 2009

 november 2008

 april 2008

 december 2007

 july 2006

 september 2005

 august 2005

 july 2005

 june 2005

 may 2005

 april 2005

 january 2005

 october 2004

 september 2004








Acknowledgement: All available information and documents in "Justice For North Caucasus Group" is provided for the "fair use". There should be no intention for ill-usage of any sort of any published item for commercial purposes and in any way or form. JFNC is a nonprofit group and has no intentions for the distribution of information for commercial or advantageous gain. At the same time consideration is ascertained that all different visions, beliefs, presentations and opinions will be presented to visitors and readers of all message boards of this site. Providing, furnishing, posting and publishing the information of all sources is considered a right to freedom of opinion, speech, expression, and information while at the same time does not necessarily reflect, represent, constitute, or comprise the stand or the opinion of this group. If you have any concerns contact us directly at: eagle@JusticeForNorthCaucasus.com


Page Last Updated: {Site best Viewed in MS-IE 1024x768 or Greater}Copyright © 2005-2009 by Justice For North Caucasus ®